Clinique Cream Shaper for Eyes (105 Chocolate Luster)

I wanted a glittery eyeliner, so I bought this. The greenish black and glitter are beautiful. It's a pencil type, but it applies smoothly and doesn't smudge.

It's not too thick, but it draws well, is soft and easy to use, and I like it. I think it might not be suitable for mucous membranes...!

This is a product I've bought many times. I use this as well as other liquid and gel liner, but when it comes to pencil liner, this is the one I recommend. You do need to sharpen the lead, but it wears out less than the retractable type, so I think it's good value for money. It's smooth to apply. It contains fine glitter, but it's barely noticeable when you apply it. I use 103 Egyptian, which isn't too black, but has an exquisite color with a slight moss green tint. I recommend it to anyone looking for a pencil-type eyeliner.

This is a product I've bought many times. I use this as well as other liquid and gel liner, but when it comes to pencil liner, this is the one I recommend. You do need to sharpen the lead, but it wears out less than the retractable type, so I think it's good value for money. It's smooth to apply. It contains fine glitter, but it's barely noticeable when you apply it. I use 103 Egyptian, which isn't too black, but has an exquisite color with a slight moss green tint. I recommend it to anyone looking for a pencil-type eyeliner.

It's very soft, so it's easy to apply. I like that it works smoothly even on dry eye areas. The color I purchased, Egyptian, makes the eyes stand out more, but it's not harsh at all, so I recommend it. I bought the Chifure pencil sharpener because someone recommended it.