It was great! My personal color is Warm Spring, and my face type is Fresh. I used to love Lip Monster's Kagerou, but in the fall and winter, my lips would peel even with lip balm. This shade lasts longer and is more moisturizing than Lip Monster. However, at this time of year, my lips might get a little dry without lip balm... (I personally can tolerate it, as they don't peel at all). Mellow Pink is a stronger pink than Kagerou. (It's probably somewhere between Pink Banana and Kagerou.) Since it's a Fresh type, I feel like it might make my lips look a little more striking, but if you tone down the colors of your eyeshadow and blush, it will look good. When I run out, I'd like to try 006 Milk Brown, which has a similar color to Kagerou, next.