Ayaka Creamy Eyeliner Pencil (22 Brown)

You can draw a very smooth line. When you blend it with the tip, it doesn't look unnatural and blends beautifully. I like that it doesn't smudge or look like a panda even in the evening. I'll definitely be buying it again.

It draws a thin line smoothly and easily. It didn't come off easily even when I used it on a rainy day. It's not advertised very widely, but I think it's surprisingly good. I recommend buying Ayaka when they offer 20% back points.

I saw this at a drugstore and bought it. It's very smooth and easy to apply. I bought the brown one, and I think the color payoff is pretty good.

It draws a thin line smoothly and easily. It didn't come off easily even when I used it on a rainy day. It's not advertised very widely, but I think it's surprisingly good. I recommend buying Ayaka when you get 20% back in points.

It's smooth and very easy to write with! And although it doesn't come off easily, it comes off easily and pleasantly when you cleanse! And best of all, it's great value for money! The fact that it can be refilled is something only Chifure can offer. I'll definitely buy it again!