Oh dear. There aren't many comments and the ratings are low, so it seems like there are mixed opinions... I recently started using this product, which came with a mini size in a gift set I bought last year. I really like it. My eyelashes are fairly dense, but thin and short. Volume mascaras tend to clump, and when I apply mascara or a top coat, the weight makes my lashes slide down, making them look like pandas, and it tires my eyelids. But this one... It doesn't clump, and it leaves me with glossy black lashes. It has just the right amount of lengthening and curl. It's not too voluminous, and it doesn't look overdone, but it gives my lashes a natural, effortless look. It's been a while since I've used black mascara! I thought, "That's great!" It didn't make my lashes look pandas, and they stayed beautiful all day. However, it did have a slight sensitivity to tears. I've always had a tendency to get watery-eyed, and with age (lol), even the slightest thing can make me tear up, regardless of my emotions, so be careful. However, it doesn't smudge as easily with tears as other mascaras. I liked it so much that I considered buying the actual product, but it seems there is also a waterproof version, so if I were to buy it, I think I would go for that one.

I was surprised to find that the one in the kit was a hit, and I was happy, but the reviews aren't that great... The brush is big. It's a mascara that you apply to your entire lash line in a flash, a quintessential overseas cosmetic. This type of mascara tends to clump, smudge, or smudge, but this one doesn't. It doesn't separate lashes, but it does create a natural volume and curl. It doesn't look overly obvious, but it really enhances your eyes. It's been a while since I've found a mascara that really tickles my fancy. It's difficult to apply to my lower lashes, or rather, impossible. The brush is too big. I use it alongside another mascara that's easier to maneuver. However, because it doesn't smudge, it's hard to remove. It leaves residue when I use my usual oil cleanser... It requires a point makeup remover, so that's a drawback.

I found this in an overseas advent calendar. The product description promised that one application would easily achieve four things: length, volume, curl, and intense color. I underestimated it and tried it for the first time on a workday. I applied it to my lashes, which I hadn't even had a perm or curler, lifting the base. It added length, but the volume was so pronounced it made my lashes look like they were there. It ended up looking a little too flashy for work, but I didn't have enough time to redo it, so I regretted underestimating the product description and went to work as is. Someone at work who doesn't talk much about personal matters asked me, "How do you get such sharp, curled lashes?" And people who do have perms also asked me what I was using, so I guess the boldness of the lashes really stood out to others. Maybe it's because of my dry eyes, but it doesn't smudge, and it definitely gives me volume, length, and curl in one application. However, since a more natural finish seems to be the norm with colored mascaras these days, I found it somewhat difficult to use—this is purely my personal opinion. I think this is a time-saving item for those who like a gorgeous finish. I also like that it can be removed with warm water without putting any strain on the lashes.

As eyeliner and mascara get older, they can easily cause itching around the eyes, so I like to buy affordable ones every three months, but I'm also looking for my favorites at department stores because I get excited. My eyelids have drooped slightly due to aging, but I have relatively thick, long, and naturally curled eyelashes. What I'm looking for is "moderate volume," "length," "no fibers," "doesn't come off with hot water," and "doesn't clump." I'm a cosmetics geek, so I bought this after watching a video by Sarah. When I used it, it straightened my eyelashes, separated them nicely, and didn't clump easily, so I thought it was a modern mascara. It reminded me of Usotsuki Mascara or Won Jongyo. However, after using it a few times, I noticed that, as everyone has said, the area under my eyes tends to turn panda-like, especially when it's exposed to tears and humidity (although it's slightly better than Givenchy, which turns panda-like even without any treatment). Like other department store cosmetics, it comes off easily with a point makeup remover, which is a good thing. I'll try using it for three months, but I don't think I'll repurchase.