INTEGRATE Matsiku Girls Lash (Feminine Volume) (BK999)

I love black volume mascara, and this one is perfect because it's affordable and can be removed with warm water. It has excellent curl retention, so I can keep my lashes curled with an eyelash curler until the evening. I've never had the mascara smudge or get panda eyes. The brush is large, so it's difficult to apply to the bottom lashes. Sometimes I use the tip of the brush to apply it and it gets on my skin.

Good points: It really does lengthen my lashes. People compliment me on how long they are when I use it. It creates a striking look even without eyeliner. The glossy jet black finish is beautiful. It's reasonably priced. It comes off easily with warm water. It's less commonly available. The fibers fall off easily in rain and snow. It's hard to use during the rainy season and snowy seasons, and the fibers fall off easily. However, it gives a natural look even without eyeliner, and it creates a striking look, so I keep buying it. So far, it's the mascara I use most often for everyday use.

My eyelashes are thin and sparse, so I only buy volume mascaras. For some reason, volume mascaras often smudge darkly under my eyes, making it difficult to choose. I feel like this is especially true with foreign department store brands. The brush is large and applies a lot of product at once, so I can get full, lush lashes in no time, but I'm often surprised when I find dark smudges under my eyes in the bathroom while I'm out. It was so expensive. I can't use it anymore. I've had this thought many times. That's why I try out a variety of affordable mascaras. This Integrate doesn't give much volume, but it doesn't smudge and has decent curl, so I think it ranks highly for everyday use. It's also nice that it can be removed with warm water. I'd love it if they came out with a super volume version.

I have eyelash extensions, so washing off with hot water is a must! I keep buying this.

I've bought this mascara many times. It builds up quite a bit of lashes and doesn't make your eyes look panda-like, which is great! I also like how it comes off easily with warm water. The packaging is also red, so it's easy to find and spot in your makeup bag. The only downside is that the brush is a bit thick, making it difficult to apply. Of all the mascaras I've used, this is my favorite! If I had to say something, I wish they'd improve the shape.