[04: Bitter Brown] I used to love Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Super Keep (Bitter Brown), but after crying my eyes out at my child's recital and coming home, the liner at the outer corner of my eyes had completely vanished... I was looking for a similar shade, and I switched to this one, which had been ranked highly on a certain website. It has great color payoff, is waterproof, and lasts a long time, but comes off easily with makeup remover. It has a metal weight, making it easy to apply with stability. The brush is firm, making it easy to apply in-line. There are other great shades, too, so I've decided to buy it again. I highly recommend this to anyone who doesn't like liquid eyeliner because it smudges. Ingredients: Water, BG, (Ethylhexyl acrylate/methyl methacrylate) copolymer, (Acrylates/methylstyrene/styrene) ammonium copolymer, Sodium polyaspartate, Sodium hyaluronate, Ceteth-20, Aluminum hydroxide, Ethylhexylglycerin, EDTA-2Na, Citric acid, Tocopherol, Phenoxyethanol, Methylparaben, Ethylparaben, Iron oxide