Compared to the Permanent Girl Volume Mascara, this one doesn't clump when applied, so it gives a beautiful finish and is easy to remove. The brown color is nice too! However, the comb is large, so it can be a bit difficult to apply to the lower lashes. The Majolica Majorca Volume Mascara I've been using for a long time has been discontinued, so I've been looking for an alternative, and this seems like a good choice.