I bought this eyeliner because it was on sale in store. The color isn't too bold, but natural, and it gets darker the more you layer it. The brush is soft, so it's easy to apply, as I like to draw thick lines. Because it's not a bold color, it creates a very natural, yet still clearly defined, finish that's great! It doesn't come off easily even with oil cleansing, so I think it's also resistant to water and sebum. I remove it after applying mascara remover. It's a light color, but it doesn't have a sheer feel, so it's easy to layer and adjust the intensity, so it draws a strong line without looking too gaudy, and I personally found a great eyeliner.