I often use Dejavu's pencil gel liner, but this eyeliner was also ranked, so I was interested in it. It's thin and can be applied smoothly, and the color goes on beautifully. I have dry eyes, so my eyes tend to get watery, but this eyeliner is weak against tears and tends to smudge, so I think Dejavu is better in this respect. It's resistant to rubbing, so it won't come off with just a little rubbing, and it seems to be better value for money than I thought.