I have dry, sensitive skin. I'm an autumn eyelid type that suits lighter colors. I have single eyelids. My eyeliner tends to fade easily. I bought the mahogany shade to go with a khaki eyeshadow palette. Khaki eyeshadow tends to lack color and look scary, but when paired with this eye pencil, it adds a healthy glow and feels right. It's a great color, and it gives a healthy glow while still giving the eye a more defined look. I also like the slight sheen. It's smooth and easy to apply, and the thickness of the pencil allows the color to be applied both inside the liner and as a subtle eyeliner, making it easy to apply. I didn't notice any color fading at all.