I'm a 1st class warm-toned, autumn-toned, and 2nd class cool-toned, winter-toned. I'm using 08. It's a pink that doesn't stand out even on me, and the finishing color is just right for smudge-proofing my eyeliner. The only problem is that the tip... it got lost in spots. This is a common problem with budget-friendly products, and maybe it's just my handling, but it's stressful, so I always apply it with a brush.