春之心持久眼线笔（哑光黑）

It's very soft and easy to apply. It's a little difficult to draw a thin line at the outer corner of the eye, though. It makes me want to try other colors too.

The C●nne section where I used to buy eyeliner at the drugstore suddenly disappeared, and instead they had this one, so I initially reluctantly bought it. But when I tried it, I realized this one was better, less likely to smudge, and easier to apply softly. The C●nne pencil's lead tends to harden and break easily after a while of use, but I've accepted that for the value of the money. This pencil is just as affordable as the C●nne pencil, and it's easy to use because it retracts and retracts. It's been a while since I started using it, and so far it hasn't hardened or broken. It even comes with a lead sharpener, but I use a different one for finer leads, so I don't think I need it. I wish they'd eliminate that and make it cheaper, but it's still a good value for the money, so if it continues like this, I'll definitely switch and repurchase.

A friend told me about this product and I used it up in about a year, so I bought it again. It doesn't smudge even when my eyes are watery, and the thick tip isn't too soft, so it's easy to line even on people in their 40s who tend to crease easily. I mainly use it as a primer for inner liner and for applying eyeliner on the outer corners of my eyes. It's cheap, but the value for money and quality are great♪

Thanks to your reviews, I found an unexpected bargain! I was looking for a smudge-proof eyeliner that wouldn't give me panda eyes in the evenings. Spring Heart? Nice to meet you! The packaging says "Made in Germany." This is my first time using German cosmetics. It's waterproof, sweat-resistant, and smudge-proof, with a soft tip that's easy to apply and dries quickly for a secure fit. While many liners don't allow you to refill the tip once it's been applied, this one does. It has a removable sharpener at the bottom, so you can adjust the tip to your desired thickness. I also use Canmake's Creamy Touch Liner, and while it's comfortable to use, it sometimes gives me panda eyes in the evenings. This one lasts, doesn't smudge, and doesn't give me panda eyes! And it's so affordable! I'm so grateful for all your reviews. I've found such a great product! I bought the matte black this time, but I'd like to try the cocoa brown one too.

I've been using and really like this makeup product lately, but I wanted to try something with a retractable tip, so I bought this. This one has a gentle, slightly pointed tip like a crayon, making it very easy to use. You only need to extend it a little, but if you extend it too much, it will break. It comes with a sharpener, so you can sharpen the tip to your desired angle. (The sharpener comes out when you pull the other side of the eyeliner, and it's instructed to extend it about 3 mm and sharpen it on the right side.) It's waterproof and resistant to sweat and water, and smudge-proof and resistant to sebum and rubbing, so I think it will stay put and stay smudge-proof all day. I'm also impressed with the good value for money. ◎ The container is a little longer than the makeup product, so I hope it lasts longer. I always read everyone's reviews. I'm having a really hard time deciding which one to use, but I'm grateful to have found a product that suits me (^^) I started using it in the winter, so I'm not sure how it will hold up in the summer heat, so I'll wait and see how it goes before deciding whether to repurchase.