Canmake持久液体眼线笔（05号灰褐色）

This is my first purchase. The tip is thin and easy to apply. The color is just right, not too black or too brown. It's rare to find a liquid eyeliner that costs less than 1,000 yen, so it's great value for money.

The brush is thin but strong, making it easy to apply even to sagging eyes. It's highly pigmented and dries quickly, so it's great for when you're prone to tears while applying makeup.

Liquid eyeliners are difficult to use and I have not used them much, but this one is easy to use as the color is light and not too bold. I would like to buy it again.

I bought this on Goshai-chan's recommendation to use on my lower lashes! Color payoff: ☆☆★★★ Ease of application: ☆★★★★ Durability: ☆☆☆★★ It has a sheer, soft color. Over time, it smudged and lost its impact on my lower lashes. In the photo, the product is on the left, and the three on the right are Creamy Touch Liners for comparison.

In the end, liquid eyeliner is my only choice! This was affordable and easy to use for me. The packaging was cute too, so I bought other colors too!