I've used the cushion cleansing oil (orange bottle) before and found it neither good nor bad, but I was attracted to it because it's available at supermarkets and contains enzymes. It leaves behind the mysterious gravel that's common with oil cleansers, but it takes twice as long as Attenir's to get to that point, so I think it's a bit of a burden. When I looked in the mirror during my skincare routine, I noticed redness around my cheekbones, so I thought it would be a bit difficult to keep up with it every day until the gravel appears! Even after emulsifying, it doesn't feel smooth, and it leaves a filmy feeling, so I double-wash. It's also a little drier than other cleansers (milk cleansers). There's no change in appearance after use, but it feels smooth when I apply lotion, so I think that's the enzyme effect. If I were to buy it again, I'd stick with the orange bottle.