The curl retention may not have been as good as I expected... The liquid is also quite delicate, so I think it would be great for people who like a delicate finish, but it's a more delicate finish than Kate's Lash For Mercreer, so to be honest, I found it quite lacking. I think the color is lovely, so it might be better to use Lash For Mercreer as a base. Personally, I don't think I'll be buying it again.