As eyeliner and mascara get older, they can easily cause itching around the eyes, so I like to buy affordable ones every three months, but I'm also looking for my favorites at department stores because I get excited. My eyelids have drooped slightly due to aging, but I have relatively thick, long, and naturally curled eyelashes. What I'm looking for is "moderate volume," "length," "no fibers," "doesn't come off with hot water," and "doesn't clump." I'm a cosmetics geek, so I bought this after watching a video by Sarah. When I used it, it straightened my eyelashes, separated them nicely, and didn't clump easily, so I thought it was a modern mascara. It reminded me of Usotsuki Mascara or Won Jongyo. However, after using it a few times, I noticed that, as everyone has said, the area under my eyes tends to turn panda-like, especially when it's exposed to tears and humidity (although it's slightly better than Givenchy, which turns panda-like even without any treatment). Like other department store cosmetics, it comes off easily with a point makeup remover, which is a good thing. I'll try using it for three months, but I don't think I'll repurchase.