I've used several MAC lip pencils in the past. They offer a wide range of colors, from natural tones to trendy shades. The pencil tip is a little stiff, but it's easy to use and doesn't smudge easily. It doesn't come with a sharpener, so first-time buyers should be aware of that. This time, I purchased "Whirl," which is said to be the most popular lip pencil these days. I wanted to match it with my recent favorites, MAC's "Alone Time" and "Buffisto," so I chose this one based on a color comparison article by a certain influencer. However, it wasn't quite what I expected. Hmm, I already have several pencils in this type of color from other companies. I was hoping for a more rose-toned shade... I guess I have to go to the counter to get the color. That said, I think "Whirl" is a very versatile color that's easy to match for those who prefer brown or beige lip colors. Those who prefer cute, blue-toned shades might not be to their liking, but it's definitely worth having. It's easy to see why this color is said to be the most popular. I've rated it 4 stars based on my personal preference for the color, but I think the product as a whole deserves 5 stars or more.