I already have Edge to Edge and this time I bought Whirl. Whirl. It's a dark rose beige, and if it was a little more blue it would be closer to the color of my lips, but the brightness is just right, and by clarifying the outline of my vague lips, even if I apply a sheer lipstick, it doesn't look sloppy and fades away, making my mouth look neater. Edge to Edge. When I use it to outline a bluish pink lipstick, it creates a contrast between my lips and skin. I'm not sure if it's because I've just started using it or if it's a matter of whether the color is strong or weak, but compared to Edge to Edge, the core of Whirl is harder and a little painful. It's a sharpener type, so I sharpen it with a MAC sharpener before using it.