I'm giving it 4 stars, but I plan to change that later. (Because I don't use it often) I forgot to review this one. It wasn't ranked among powder eyebrow products. I'd used the #1 Kate palette a few times, but the color payoff wasn't great, so a beauty advisor recommended it as my next purchase. Also, this eyebrow palette apparently can also be used to create under-eye bags, so I thought it might kill two birds with one stone (lol). The method she taught me was: If you don't like your current brows (because it's permanent makeup, lol), first erase them with MAC concealer, then apply MAC powder foundation (to remove oil and make it easier to apply), and then use an eyebrow pencil for the tail of your brows. (MAC) The light beige shade at the top of this palette is used as a highlighter by hand under the tail of your brows. The slightly brown shade in the middle is applied to the beginning of your brows with the rounded brush provided. The dark brown shade at the bottom is applied to the tail of your brows with the diagonally cut brush provided. Finally, use eyebrow gel (from MAC) to blend your brows. It's like making the hairs stand up. I remember writing about how to create under-eye bags somewhere, but I'll add it if I can find the paper. I think it was like drawing a line with the middle color. Unlike Kate, the color is vibrant. Comes with a mirror. Made in Italy.