Heavy Rotation's regular brush was renewed, and my favorite pink brown was discontinued, so I purchased this pink brown. Upon application, the color appears to be the same. The bottle color is pink brown, but the color is darker when applied. Neither the pink nor the brown is overpowering, and it blends well with dark hair. (If you scrub it hard, the brown comes out.) I'm a cool winter type, so without a pink (or blue) tint, my brows tend to look out of place. I've been seeing a lot of gray eyebrow mascaras lately, so I thought it might work with my dark hair, so I tried it. Unfortunately, it ended up looking washed out and making my face look dull, perhaps due to the popularity of ash-toned mascaras and the trend toward thin brows. (Perhaps ash-toned mascaras don't work well with darker cool winter types?) This pink brown blends naturally with dark hair, so I hope it doesn't get discontinued. Furthermore, I wish they'd bring back the pink brown brush in their regular coloring eyebrow line! It's the same price as the regular brush, but it's half the size, and since I don't have thin brows, this brush is too small and difficult to apply. I hope the regular pink brown brush is back.