I usually go for the Long WP Black, but the Volume Brown was on sale for half price, so I bought it. I have absolute confidence in Heroine Make's waterproof products. This one is no disappointment either. If you layer too much volume, it can look a bit messy, but if you apply a small amount once, it leaves your lashes looking full and beautiful. I found out after I bought it that it was renewed this year. Is it a clearance sale? lol If it's even better after the renewal, I'll buy it again. I've loved it since I was a teenager! It doesn't come off with oil cleansers, so I use Heroine Make remover.