I struggled, but I ended up choosing the darker one. I like American-style makeup, so I prefer fuller foundation. Whether it's blush, bronzer, or eyeshadow, I prefer cream types over powder, so this product caught my eye. It's easy to use, and it's easier to blend and control the intensity than powder. If you feel it's too dark, you can tone it down by taking a small amount of foundation on a puff and tapping it on. It's a great product that's easy to use.